A full week of effort after some time off in Florida…it’s exhausting. Maybe the French have the right idea with their short work-week.
Seems like there was lots of driving this week. An LHH class here, a career networking event there, and some final cleanup at the storage unit. Am scheduled to be completely storage unit free by the end of the month. Have sold several treasures, gave some away, and have numerous other golden items still on Craigslist. Come on…somebody needs to buy those 16 old wooden windows. You know you want them!
Ok, this is supposed to be a blog about writing, communication, and general nonsense. Think I’ve covered the latter pretty well lately so let’s pull over here to the scenic lookout and take a gander at a pet peeve. (What? You thought this was always sweetness, and ribbons, and puppies?)
In addition to the gorgeous view from our lookout spot, there’s dead horse in the brush that needs some additional beating. It’s the which horse. Or, the that horse.
I’m not sure when it happened, but people who should know better have hijacked the word that, are keeping it bound and gagged in the basement, and have trotted out the word which as a suitable replacement.
It’s not.
Which is an adjective. You use it to indicate a choice: I can’t decide which shoes to wear.
That is, primarily, a pronoun: That is the tool you are looking for.
I know, there are exceptions. The word that is a complex little bugger. It can be a pronoun, adjective, conjunction, or adverb. Which, it’s cousin, needs less therapy but does, on occasion, crop up as a pronoun but (buckle up ’cause here it comes) it shouldn’t. (“He is the man that started it,” is just wrong. It should be “He is the man who started it.” He is a who, not a that, a which, or an it.
Which and that should never be pronouns. People are who. We always were, we always are, we always will be who. To substitute which or that for who denigrates and marginalizes people and I don’t think that’s very nice.
My gut feeling is that somewhere back in the late 21st century, marketing , newspaper, and broadcasting people started substituting which for that because they thought it sounded better; more intellectual. Well, it doesn’t. It sounds like you don’t know the difference between which and that, not to mention who.
Don’t believe me? Start listening to the words people use on TV and radio, in newspapers and magazine, and in your office communication. Count the number of times you hear the words which and that and see which one leads the pack.
And, don’t tell me “Oh, it doesn’t matter. They’ll know what I mean.” No, they won’t. At least, the one’s who learned the rules of grammar won’t because your meaning is unclear based on your sloppy choice of words. You have purposefully muddied your meaning.
Remember, your goal is clear, concise, precise communication. Anything else is dishonest.
So, stop it. Use which to designate a choice. Use that to identify a thing. Use who when referring to people.
Let’s get on down the road and enjoy the view and the journey and leave this poor horse alone. Don’t make me stop this car and go over there again.